The Museum of Applied Arts and Sciences acknowledges Australia’s First Nations Peoples as the Traditional Owners and Custodians of the land and gives respect to the Elders – past and present – and through them to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples.
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples are advised that the MAAS website contains a range of Indigenous Cultural Material. This includes artworks, artifacts, images and recordings of people who may have passed away, and other objects which may be culturally sensitive.
H6858 Musical automaton,  'L'Avocat' (The Lawyer), barrister standing behind podium, papier mache / textile / wood / metal / glass, maker unknown, Paris, France, 1895-1905. Click to enlarge.

French musical automaton, ‘L’Avocat’ (The Lawyer), 1895-1905

Made
This is an automaton, a mechanical figure in the form of a barrister, which was made to move as if spontaneously through a concealed clockwork mechanism. Made around 1900, the barrister stands pompously behind a podium, opening and closing his mouth, blinking, tilting his head and moving his arms up and down, brandishing a written document. The device reveals its main purpose, to entertain, by producing music rather than spoken words.

While its maker is unknown, this musical barrister is very similar to automata designed and made by Henri Phalibois in Paris, France, from 1895. This unsigned automaton (bearing the numbers 36 and 665, but not the initials HP) is probably a copy by another French maker.

People have been making human-shaped string-controlled puppets for about 4000 years. Around 2000 years ago, Hero of Alexandria created a musical theatre programmed with strings and pulleys and incorporating moving human figurines. And 800 years ago Ismail Al-Jazari made a group of automata that played a harp, a flute and two drums, all programmed by a pegged drum. The barrister automaton sits within this long tradition of entertainments shaped like humans and moved mechanically.

What makes us human? The puppets and automata arose from this question, and they prompt us to continue asking it. Beyond our form, the answer encompasses thinking, speaking, writing, teaching, making music, inventing, drawing, crafting, and self-awareness. The three most accomplished 18th century automata have human form, embody inventiveness and craft, and mirror another of these actions. Made by Pierre Jaquet-Droz, one writes, one draws, and one plays piano. The barrister, made over 100 years later, can only mime speaking. Perhaps he is a clever advocate of his clients' rights, but we can't be sure as he lacks a voice and appears suspiciously theatrical, with large eyes, red lips and flamboyantly curled wig. Perhaps he is a buffoon.

In the early years of the 19th century, Mary Shelley created the character of Frankenstein's monster, making us question how wisely we employ our inventiveness. The impulse that led people to create automata with human form has led to many useful humanoid robots, but robots have made many people redundant and we wonder which jobs will disappear next. Some thinkers picture a future in which justice is dispensed by rules-based machines totally lacking in humanity, but the automaton barrister does not take us there. After all, it was intended to stand in a shop window, advertising the services of a flesh-and-blood barrister, and its theatrical appearance was intended to ensure its visibility.

Debbie Rudder

Summary

Object No.

H6858

Object Statement

Musical automaton, 'L'Avocat' (The Lawyer), barrister standing behind podium, papier mache / textile / wood / metal / glass, maker unknown, Paris, France, 1895-1905

Physical Description

Musical automaton featuring a male lawyer in black robe and wig standing behind a podium. The right hand is stretched out, while the left hand holds a rolled document. The lawyer is automated, and the front part of his jaw is jointed so he could appear to speak. The mechanism, made up of wooden cogs and wires, is underneath the podium. A metal key for winding the mechanism protrudes from the side of the podium to the lawyer's left. The quill pen has broken off the inkwell on top of the podium and is tucked into the pocket of the lawyer's robe.

The automaton plays a tune while the arms move up and down, the eyes blink and the mouth opens and closes. Under the lawyer's robe, a clockwork motor drives a music box by rotating a brass cylinder; pins placed around the cylinder at selected positions (creating a program for the music to be played) interact with a steel comb with teeth of differing lengths; the longer teeth are weighted with lead so they produce bass notes. Movements are controlled by pull rods operating from a drum fitted with a series of cams. The whole unit is mounted on a wooden board covered with brown plush fabric.

Marks

Number stamped on bedplate "36"
Number scratched onto the cylinder "665"

Dimensions

Height

710 mm

Width

360 mm

Depth

280 mm

Production

Source

Credit Line

Gift of Trevitt, L E , 1961

Acquisition Date

7 July 1961

Cite this Object

Harvard

French musical automaton, 'L'Avocat' (The Lawyer), 1895-1905 2020, Museum of Applied Arts & Sciences, accessed 24 November 2020, <https://ma.as/246791>

Wikipedia

{{cite web |url=https://ma.as/246791 |title=French musical automaton, 'L'Avocat' (The Lawyer), 1895-1905 |author=Museum of Applied Arts & Sciences |access-date=24 November 2020 |publisher=Museum of Applied Arts & Sciences, Australia}}
This object is currently on display in Technology & Innovation at the Museums Discovery Centre.